Forget tricks—Crumbl’s Halloween cookie lineup is a box of pure treats for fall 2025. Known for their weekly cookie drops and viral social flavor reveals, Crumbl has transformed their bakeries into haunted houses of sugar for Halloween week, packing the case with new flavors, festive decor, and a few graveyard surprises.
So, what’s inside this year’s Crumbl Halloween box? It’s a mix of returning fan favorites and bold new creations. Expect the Pumpkin Cheesecake Cookie, a riff on the brand’s classic cheesecake style, featuring a pumpkin cookie base topped with tangy, creamy frosting for true pumpkin pie vibes. There’s also a Dirt Cake Cookie, decked out with chocolate, cookie crumbs, and gummy worms for a dessert that feels equal parts nostalgia and fun. Chocolate lovers can also choose the decadent Chocolate Peanut Butter Brownie ft. Reese’s Pieces—thick, fudgy, and loaded with peanut butter candies on top. For color and crunch, the Halloween Confetti Milkshake Cookie blends creamy vanilla icing with bursts of seasonal sprinkles, channeling the milkshake trend Crumbl’s customers have been going nuts for.
Alongside these festive flavors, Crumbl’s Halloween box features the French Toast Cookie, a fluffy, buttery cookie topped with cinnamon-egg wash, a dollop of buttercream, sweet syrup drizzle, and a sprinkle of powdered sugar. This treat channels cozy breakfast vibes with every bite, bringing yet another nostalgic twist to the seasonal menu. Rounding out the menu are the Cookie Dough Cookie, a brown sugar cookie topped with creamy cookie dough buttercream and chunks of cookie dough, and the Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chunk Cookie—a chunkier take on chocolate chip, filled with gooey semi-sweet chocolate and finished with flaky sea salt.
But the real twist this Halloween? Each Crumbl store hides one “Graveyard” cookie: a retired favorite or legendary flavor brought back for a limited time, haunting locations across the country. Which throwback cookie is haunting your local bakery is a secret revealed only in the store and via the Crumbl App, encouraging fans to visit, order online, or check social feeds to discover which flavor returned from the Crumbl afterlife.
Presentation is as much a part of Crumbl’s Halloween as the cookies themselves. Each treat is decked out in orange, black, and purple hues, with some stores adding themed packaging and promotional décor so the unboxing experience is as Instagrammable as the taste test.
Crumbl’s fan base is hard to impress. They know the difference between a flavor gimmick and a cookie worth lining up for. This year, the limited-edition Halloween lineup finds a sweet spot: playful, nostalgic, and genuinely craveable, whether you go for the rich chocolate styles or the photogenic, candy-studded creations. For Halloween 2025, the cookie brand’s “more treats than tricks” promise is the real deal, and you don’t need a costume to get in on the sugar rush.
