Love Island finalist Teddy Soares has hinted at a possible return to the villa – four years after being at the centre of the most complained-about episode in the show’s history.
The 30-year-old, who is currently single, admitted All Stars could be on the cards when a fan asked him on social media.
When asked, “All Stars 2026?”, Teddy replied: “Who knows what the future holds.”
Back in 2021, Teddy was coupled with Faye Winter, 28, and they finished third. However, their time in the villa was tainted by explosive arguments, with one confrontation becoming the most complained-about moment in Love Island history.
Credit: ITV
Faye racked up a whopping 36,324 Ofcom complaints after an on-screen meltdown that viewers branded “toxic” and “difficult to watch.”
Teddy has previously admitted he struggled watching the show back then.
“I haven’t actually tuned into Love Island in a while – since my own series. Maybe a little bit of PTSD, I don’t know. Obviously now, I’ve moved so far along with my own podcast and there are things I’m working on. It’s interesting now when I see certain clips, it does trigger me. My heart starts pumping and more often than not, it’s really good memories, so it’s a shame.”
Their early relationship in the villa included several tense moments, such as a scene where Faye swore and screamed in Teddy’s face. Other scenes saw him sharing a kiss with bombshell Clarisse, before admitting he was “technically single” during a chat with the other boys.
Credit: ITV
The relationship ultimately ended in tears, leaving fans pleading for production to intervene, while Faye later faced death threats following the fallout.
Despite all this, Teddy’s comment suggests he isn’t completely ruling out a return, meaning we could see him back on our screens for Love Island All Stars next year.
For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.
Featured image credit: ITV
