Love Island 2025 was a blast, and it’s honestly gutting it’s all over. What a series it’s been, with a great cast who kept us fed by being very volatile and arguing all the time. Pure bliss. None of us know what to do with ourselves now it’s over – but worry not, because All Stars is already on its way. I know Love Island All Stars is never actually that good, but perhaps now we have an influx of Islanders we actually like maybe the 2025 Islanders can save it. Here’s a quick rundown of the absolute icons of Love Island 2025 that we must see return as Islanders for All Stars now its booked and blessed for its 2026 return.
One thing, though – no one currently in a couple can come back. Sorry Shakira and Yasmin!
Helena
via ITV
Look, don’t boo me – but I think Helena could have a Luca styled redemption arc on Love Island All Stars. She’s a big character, and we need to see what she’s not like when she’s obsessed with Harry or attached at the hip to Meg. I think she’s very likely, personally – and think she could do alright.
Alima
via ITV
An early fave for most of us who got constantly disrespected in the villa this year. I feel like she was always cursed with abysmal men. Give her the chance to come back and actually get what she deserves – someone nice.
Emma
Via ITV
Everyone loves her bizarre ways and she was good TV. Again I’d like to see her have the chance to be an Islander without Harry there – because her entire existence on the show this year was dominated by the fact she was his ex.
Andrada
Via ITV
Put simply, reality TV gold. Of everyone, it’s our Andrada who absolutely devoured in the final week of the show and had everyone obsessed with her. She will never hold back and always give us viral moments, which is exactly what the admittedly pretty dead Love Island All Stars actually needs.
Giorgio
via ITV
Probably one of the most beloved boys of this year’s Love Island 2025 Islanders who didn’t make it to the final or do well romantically – he’d be a great choice for All Stars. He came across brilliantly on the show and I just feel like his right person wasn’t in the cast this year.
Malisha
Via ITV
Absolute icon. Up there with Andrada as the one who just always stands on business. I think if she’d stayed longer this year she would have been in the group with Shakira, Yasmin and Toni and I hate that her entire time was just linked to Dejon and Meg. That being said, was there a single episode she appeared in where she wasn’t iconic? Nope.
NOT BLU
via ITV
Please read that and understand it ITV. We are being SERIOUS.
For all the latest Love Island news and gossip, like The Holy Church of Love Island on Facebook.
